How the Canada superficial loss check works
Beta · last updated 2026-11-12 · applies to the current version of the Canada checker
This page documents each rule the Canada checker applies and each situation it does not judge. When the data in your files can't settle a question, the checker says "Can't tell" and names what would settle it. It reports what the files you imported show, and it doesn't certify any result. It is not tax advice and its numbers are not a tax return. Open the checker, or read the guide to the rule.
What it checks
- The rule. Under section 54 of the Income Tax Act, a loss on selling property is superficial when you, or a person affiliated with you, acquire the same or identical property in the period that starts 30 days before the sale and ends 30 days after it, and at the end of that period you or a person affiliated with you still owns that property or has a right to acquire it. A superficial loss is deemed to be nil (section 40(2)(g)(i)).
- The 61 days, by settlement date. The period runs from 30 days before to 30 days after the settlement date of the sale, and both end days count. A purchase counts by its own settlement date, except where a purchase traded on the period's last day settles after it, which is one of the open questions below. In CRA's view the settlement date, not the trade date, is the date of disposition for calculating a capital gain or loss. That is what CRA technical interpretation 2015-0588981C6 (APFF roundtable, Oct. 9, 2015) says in French (our translation); its English summary asks which date converts foreign-currency proceeds from a stock market sale and answers "Position Adoptée: The settlement date." Its T5008 guide (T4091) says in Box 14 to enter "the month and day on which the transaction was completed (the settlement date)". CRA says a technical interpretation "is not determinative of the tax treatment of a specific taxpayer's situation" (IC70-6R12), and we found no CRA statement that applies the settlement date to the superficial loss period by name, so the checker states it in "What this check assumes".
- The still-owns test. The law asks whether you, or a person affiliated with you, still owns the property bought in the period when the period ends. Read for each person or plan on its own, a loss isn't superficial when nobody still holds what they bought, even if older shares are held. CRA also works out the amount as if all of you were one person, and that reading may decide this too. The checker doesn't choose: when the two readings differ, the sale shows "Can't tell" with both, and the totals leave it out.
- CRA's formula. When the loss is superficial, the part denied is the least of S, P and B, divided by S, times the loss. S is the units sold in this sale. P is the units you, your spouse and the registered plans of either of you bought in the period, counting purchases made before the sale and purchases later sold again. B is the units all of them held at the end of the period, including units held from before the period.
- The strict reading. The formula is a CRA administrative concession. The statute, read strictly, denies the whole loss, so each superficial result also shows that amount.
- Where a denied loss goes. The denied amount is added to the adjusted cost base of the replacement shares (section 53(1)(f)), whoever holds them, in proportion to the replacement units each holder has at the end of the period, as CRA described in technical interpretation 2022-0940941C6. A part that sits in a registered plan is shown as lost for good. For an RRSP, CRA adds that part to the cost base of the RRSP's shares (2022-0940941C6), but it also says you cannot claim a deduction for "any capital losses within your RRSP" (CRA, RRSP deduction limit). For a TFSA, a CI Global Asset Management explainer (February 26, 2021) calls a loss denied by a purchase in the plan "permanently denied"; we found no CRA statement on a TFSA's part, and none on a RRIF's, an FHSA's or an RESP's. When a holder's data is missing, for example your spouse's accounts, the split isn't certain: no part is added to any ACB, and the numbers of the pools that might hold the replacement are withheld after the period.
Cautious mode
While the questions below are open, the checker doesn't pick a reading. A sale whose result one of them could change shows "Can't tell", names the question and shows both readings, and the year's totals leave it out until the question is settled.
Dates
- Settlement dates. A settlement date in your file is used as it is. Without one, the checker works it out from the trade date and marks it as derived: one business day later from May 27, 2024 on the TSX and from May 28, 2024 in the US; two from Sept. 5, 2017; three before that. It counts business days only, using the TSX holiday rules and the NYSE holiday rules. It also leaves out days when an exchange is open but nothing settles. In Canada those are Nov. 11 and, from 2021, Sept. 30: the TSX trades on both, and its own notices call each a "Banking Holiday ONLY" and a "non-settlement day", as the CDS holiday schedule also shows. When one falls on a weekend the notices for 2018 and 2023 put it on the Monday after, and the checker does the same; no notice yet covers Sept. 30 on a Sunday (2029), and the checker leaves that Monday a settlement day. For a US trade it treats Columbus Day and Veterans Day as days nothing settles, though the NYSE is open. A date near these days is one of the open questions below.
- The same day. When a security is bought and sold on the same day and your file has no time of day, the checker works through every order those rows could have happened in. A sale whose ACB is the same in every order is shown, with the purchases counted first. A sale whose ACB depends on the order shows no numbers, and the holding shows none from that day until it is sold out. On a day with more than six such rows for one holding, none of its sales that day shows numbers unless all of the purchases cost the same per share. A day where only some rows have a time is treated as having none. A file that gives each row's time of day settles the order.
- Dividend reinvestments. A reinvestment counts as a purchase. Without a settlement date it is dated on the day the file shows, because the units are credited that day.
- The year a sale counts in. A sale counts in the year it settles, because in CRA's view the settlement date is the date of disposition (2015-0588981C6). For 2026 the last trade date that settles in 2026 is Wed Dec 30, 2026, settling Thu Dec 31. A sale traded on Thu Dec 31 settles Mon Jan 4, 2027 and counts for 2027. The checker computes this line for both markets and shows it with the totals.
- Totals so far. A year's totals say "so far" until the last 30-day period of that year has ended (Jan. 30 for 2026), because a 30-day period from the last days of a year runs into January. After that day they stop saying "so far", and they say incomplete while any sale is left out of them.
- Periods still running. A loss whose period hasn't ended is "Can't tell". The checker gives the first trade date for a purchase that settles after the period. A purchase traded on the last day of the period settles after it, but the right to buy it may still count, so that date is the day after.
To work out one sale's period and CRA's formula without importing files, use the superficial loss calculator; it counts the period from the same settlement dates.
Exchange rates
US-dollar amounts are converted with the Bank of Canada daily USD/CAD rate on the settlement date of each trade. CRA's Schedule 3 page says "the day of the transaction" without saying which date that is for shares. In technical interpretation 2015-0588981C6, CRA said US-dollar proceeds from a stock market sale are converted at the rate the Bank of Canada posted at noon on the settlement date, and, asked whether a taxpayer could use either date the same way every year, said the taxpayer must follow that approach (our translation of the French original). An interpretation is not determinative of a specific taxpayer's situation (IC70-6R12) and many tools use the trade date, so each sale also shows its result with trade-date rates, and a sale whose result differs between the two shows "Can't tell". On a day with no published rate, the previous business day's rate is used, up to seven days back, and the sale says so. A rate stated on a row in your file is used as it is. This version's rates run from Jan. 3, 2017 to Nov. 10, 2026; the site adds the latest rates each time it is updated. A US-dollar trade that settles after the last rate, with no rate in your file, has no numbers; a later version of this page adds later rates. US dollar amounts are converted with the Bank of Canada daily exchange rate (series FXUSDCAD, 2017-01-03 to 2026-11-10). The Bank publishes these as indicative rates only; the underlying data is sourced from LSEG. Source: Bank of Canada, https://www.bankofcanada.ca/terms/
Adjusted cost base
Identical shares are pooled at average cost for each taxpayer: you and your spouse each have your own pool for each security, across your non-registered accounts. The checker keeps no average cost for registered accounts, because their sales give no taxable capital gain and no deductible capital loss. For an RRSP, CRA says "Any income you earn in the RRSP is usually exempt from tax as long as the funds remain in the plan" (CRA, RRSPs) and that you cannot claim a deduction for "any capital losses within your RRSP". For a TFSA, it says "any income you earn through interest, dividends or capital gains are generally tax-free" (CRA, What is a TFSA). We found no current CRA page on losses inside a TFSA, or on the other plans, and the checker treats every registered plan the same way. Their purchases and holdings still count in the superficial loss test. A sale's gain or loss is its proceeds, less its outlays, less the ACB of the units sold, each rounded to cents, so the row adds up as shown. The pool itself keeps full precision. The checker adds a denied loss to the pool at the end of the 30-day period; some tools add it earlier, which is one of the open questions below. The ACB of fund and trust units leaves out returns of capital and reinvested distributions that appear only on T3 or T5 slips.
Your spouse and your registered plans
A spouse or common-law partner, and the registered plans of either of you (RRSP, RRIF, TFSA, FHSA, RESP), have their purchases and holdings counted for this rule, with different footing. A spouse's RRSP or TFSA rests on the statute's wording: section 251.1(1)(g) makes a trust affiliated with a person who is affiliated with its majority-interest beneficiary, and a spouse is affiliated with you (section 251.1(1)(a)); CIBC's explainer names a trust "of which you or your spouse or partner are a majority interest beneficiary (such as your RRSP or TFSA)". The sources for an RESP and an FHSA are thin. Where an RESP, an FHSA or another registered plan (an RDSP, a DPSP) could decide a result, the checker shows "Can't tell" with both readings, because whether such a plan counts as affiliated with you isn't settled. CRA took the view that a spouse's RRSP counts in technical interpretation 2021-0896031C6 (the APFF roundtable of 2021): the RRSP trust of the seller's spouse, of which the spouse is the majority-interest beneficiary, is affiliated with the seller. The checker asks whether you have a spouse and whether all of their accounts are imported, and it never assumes an answer. If their accounts aren't all here, a loss their purchases could change shows as "Can't tell", and your spouse's non-registered sales and holdings show no ACB or gain or loss. An account you can't import, such as a joint account, can be added as "An account I haven't imported", and the losses it could affect then show as "Can't tell". A registered plan you list there doesn't hide your non-registered sales' ACB or gain or loss; a non-registered account you list hides its owner's.
Your own accounts
Are all of your own accounts here? The checker asks this before it shows results, and it can't verify the answer. Your own accounts means each non-registered account, RRSP, RRIF, TFSA, FHSA and RESP you hold, at any broker, and a joint account (list it under "An account I haven't imported"). A purchase in an account that isn't here can make a loss superficial. If some aren't here, a loss they could change shows as "Can't tell". If you answer No, your non-registered sales show no ACB or gain or loss. A plan you list under "An account I haven't imported" doesn't hide them; a non-registered account you list hides its owner's.
Identical property
Shares are matched by ticker and market (the TSX or the US). A ticker that appears on both markets is withheld until you say whether the two lines are the same shares: one company listed on two exchanges is the same property, a ticker can also name two companies, and whether a Canadian depositary receipt (CDR) is the same property as the US share isn't settled: we found no CRA statement. Both lines show "Can't tell" until you answer. You can link two lines under different tickers, such as CNR on the TSX and CNI on the NYSE. The checker does not judge two different securities that might still be identical property, such as two ETFs on one index.
The import step
- Interactive Brokers files are read as they are, by a reader that has not been run on a real Canadian file, so check the results against your statements. For other brokers you map the columns once: trade date, symbol, action, quantity and price, and optionally the settlement date, time, market, currency, fees, exchange rate, account, description and asset type. The mapping is remembered for files with the same headers.
- Date order and currency are asked, never assumed. A market stated in your file, or by a symbol's prefix or suffix such as TSX: or .TO, is used; otherwise the checker asks for the market of each ticker in each currency, so a Canadian-dollar line and a US-dollar line of one ticker are separate. A file whose dates prove both orders is refused, and so is a file that writes numbers with a decimal comma.
- One ticker is one ticker however it is written: BRK.B, BRK B and BRK-B are read as the same ticker.
- Options, warrants, rights, subscription receipts and convertibles are not imported as trades. A row that looks like one withholds the security it is on; when the file doesn't say which security that is, the review asks. A short sale, a split, a transfer, a return of capital, and any action your word lists don't name also withhold the security, and so does a buy, sell or reinvestment row that names a symbol but no quantity.
- Futures and crypto are not imported as trades, and they aren't left out either: the superficial loss definition isn't limited to securities, and this checker doesn't work out futures or crypto, so it can't tell here. A row your Asset type column calls one, or whose symbol is written like one (/ESZ6, ESZ6, ES=F, BTC-USD, BTCUSD, BTC.X), is held back and named on its own symbol, even if a Stock label says otherwise. A ticker that may be one and may be a stock or fund (BTC, ES, LTC) is asked about in the review, every file, and Import waits for the answer, unless its Market column or suffix says Canada. A file that also holds a future or a pair doesn't get Shares as an answer. A coin or root not on our list (KC or ZEC, say) isn't known and is read as shares. Ask a tax professional about these rows.
- Each account has one continuous history. A file that overlaps one already imported is refused, or replaces it if you choose. When files leave a gap, only the latest run is checked, and the checker says so.
- For each account you say what it held at the start of its files, because shares held from before still count at the end of a period. A non-registered account's positions need their total ACB; without it, that security shows no numbers.
What the checker can't see
- Options, warrants, rights, subscription receipts and convertibles: a security with one is withheld, but only when the file shows it as one.
- Short sales.
- Joint accounts, and accounts of a corporation or trust you control.
- Splits, mergers, spin-offs, transfers in kind and returns of capital: the security is withheld when your file has a row for one.
- Returns of capital and reinvested ("phantom") distributions that appear only on T3 or T5 slips. They change the ACB of fund and trust units, so for those units the ACB here can be too high or too low.
- Two different tickers that may be identical property, such as two ETFs on one index, unless you link them.
- Shares an account held before its files start, unless you list them.
- US-dollar trades before Jan. 3, 2017 or after this version's last exchange rate, unless your file states a rate.
- How to enter a superficial loss on Schedule 3.
Questions not yet settled
We found no answer that settles these for every taxpayer: CRA has said nothing on them, or what it has said leaves room. While they are open, a result one of them could change shows "Can't tell" and names the question. Ask a CPA about any that affects a sale of yours.
- Whether CRA's "as if all the parties were one person" reading also decides if a loss is superficial. Read that way, a loss can be superficial when you, your spouse or a plan bought in the period and sold again, while older shares were still held at its end. Where it could change a result, the sale shows "Can't tell" with both readings.
- When a denied loss is added to the replacement shares' ACB: at the end of the 30-day period, as the checker does, or when the replacement was bought, as some tools do. The answer changes the ACB of shares sold during the period and after it, so those sales show "Can't tell".
- A purchase traded by the period's last day that settles after it. Counted by settlement date it is outside the period; the law's "right to acquire" wording could count it. Where it could change a result, the sale shows "Can't tell" with both readings.
- One purchase replacing two loss sales. CRA's formula applied to each sale on its own can count the same shares twice, so the later sale shows "Can't tell". The checker counts the replacement for the earlier sale.
- A purchase in an RESP, an FHSA or another registered plan (an RDSP, a DPSP). Whether such a plan counts as affiliated with you for this rule isn't settled. Where it could change a result, the sale shows "Can't tell" with both readings.
- Which day's exchange rate converts a US-dollar trade. CRA's 2015 interpretation (2015-0588981C6) uses the settlement date for a sale's proceeds, and the checker uses that date for purchases as well; its Schedule 3 page says only "the day of the transaction", and an interpretation is not determinative of a specific taxpayer's situation. Many tools use the trade date, so each sale also shows its result with trade-date rates, and a sale whose result differs between the two (a gain one way and a loss the other, say) shows "Can't tell".
- Settlement dates worked out near Sept. 30 and Nov. 11. The TSX trades on both days but nothing settles on them (Sept. 30 from 2021), and the checker follows the TSX notices that put a weekend one on the Monday after (read for 2018 and 2023). No notice covers Sept. 30 on a Sunday yet (2029), so the checker leaves that Monday a settlement day. Check a worked-out date near these days against your broker's confirmation. This affects no settlement date worked out for a trade before Sept. 29, 2027.
- Is a CDR the same property as the share it represents? We found no CRA statement. If you say one of two lines is a CDR, both show "Can't tell".
Your data
Your trades, accounts and answers stay in a separate local database in your browser. Nothing is uploaded. The backups you download are files only you hold. The button named "Clear my data" deletes everything the Canada checker keeps, and leaves the US checker's data alone. The example trades are never saved.