FXAIX and VFIAX: are they substantially identical for the wash-sale rule?
By Wash-Sale Guardian (who's behind it) · Published 2026-11-12 · Last updated 2026-11-12 · How the checker works
Two S&P 500 mutual funds, one at Fidelity and one at Vanguard: FXAIX, which Fidelity says normally invests at least 80% of its assets in the index’s stocks, and VFIAX, the Admiral Shares of Vanguard 500 Index Fund, which Vanguard says seeks to track the index. Moving a loss from one fund company to the other doesn’t change the question the law asks, and we found no IRS ruling that answers it for these two.
The facts, from each issuer’s own page
| Fact | FXAIX | VFIAX |
|---|---|---|
| Full name | Fidelity 500 Index Fund | Vanguard 500 Index Fund Admiral Shares |
| Issuer | Fidelity | Vanguard |
| Type | Mutual fund | Mutual fund |
| Index, as the issuer names it | S&P 500 Index “Normally investing at least 80% of assets in common stocks included in the S&P 500® Index.” | S&P 500 Index “Vanguard 500 Index Fund seeks to track the investment performance of the Standard & Poor’s 500 Index” |
| Share class of | No other share class named on the pages we read | Vanguard 500 Index Fund “Vanguard 500 Index Fund Admiral Shares” |
| Source | Read November 12, 2026 Fidelity, FXAIX summary prospectus (April 29, 2026) | Read November 12, 2026 Vanguard, VFIAX fund page |
Every fact in the table is from the issuer’s own page for the fund, read on the date shown; the quoted words are the issuer’s. Issuers rename funds and change indexes, so check each page before you rely on it.
What kind of pair this is: two funds from different issuers on the same index
FXAIX and VFIAX name the same index in their issuers’ own words: FXAIX normally invests at least 80% of its assets in stocks included in the S&P 500 Index, and VFIAX seeks to track the S&P 500 Index. They are separate funds from different companies, FXAIX from Fidelity and VFIAX from Vanguard, each with its own shares.
This is the gray zone. One reading says the shared index makes the two funds substantially identical; another says two separate funds from two issuers are different securities. We found no IRS ruling that settles it, and IRC §1091, its regulation and Publication 550 name no fund pairs. Because the index is the same, a pair like this carries more of that risk than two funds on different indexes. Ask a CPA or EA before relying on a swap between them.
The law in its own words
Read on 2026-11-12. The statute, IRC §1091(a):
“In the case of any loss claimed to have been sustained from any sale or other disposition of shares of stock or securities where it appears that, within a period beginning 30 days before the date of such sale or disposition and ending 30 days after such date, the taxpayer has acquired (by purchase or by an exchange on which the entire amount of gain or loss was recognized by law), or has entered into a contract or option so to acquire, substantially identical stock or securities, then no deduction shall be allowed under section 165 unless the taxpayer is a dealer in stock or securities and the loss is sustained in a transaction made in the ordinary course of such business.”
The regulation, Treas. Reg. §1.1091-1(a), in its own words:
“A taxpayer cannot deduct any loss claimed to have been sustained from the sale or other disposition of stock or securities if, within a period beginning 30 days before the date of such sale or disposition and ending 30 days after such date (referred to in this section as the 61-day period), he has acquired (by purchase or by an exchange upon which the entire amount of gain or loss was recognized by law), or has entered into a contract or option so to acquire, substantially identical stock or securities. However, this prohibition does not apply (1) in the case of a taxpayer, not a corporation, if the sale or other disposition of stock or securities is made in connection with the taxpayer’s trade or business, or (2) in the case of a corporation, a dealer in stock or securities, if the sale or other disposition of stock or securities is made in the ordinary course of its business as such dealer.”
The regulation’s second sentence is older than the statute’s present words: its history note shows the regulation last amended in 1967. In 1984, Pub. L. 98-369, section 106(b), put the dealer-only words quoted above into the statute, for sales after December 31, 1984. Before that, the statute denied the deduction “under section 165(c)(2)”, the paragraph for an individual’s losses in a transaction “entered into for profit, though not connected with a trade or business”, which is what the regulation’s clause (1) reflects (the amendment notes on the statute’s page give both wordings). This site follows the statute. Our guide to traders and the mark-to-market election covers what that means for a trader; ask a CPA or EA about your own case.
IRS Publication 550 (2025), under “Substantially identical” in its wash sales section:
“In determining whether stock or securities are substantially identical, you must consider all the facts and circumstances in your particular case. Ordinarily, stocks or securities of one corporation are not considered substantially identical to stocks or securities of another corporation. However, they may be substantially identical in some cases. For example, in a reorganization, the stocks and securities of the predecessor and successor corporations may be substantially identical.”
- Neither the statute nor the regulation defines “substantially identical.”
- Publication 550’s wash sales section says nothing about mutual funds, exchange-traded funds or index funds: the test it gives is the “facts and circumstances” sentence above.
- We found no IRS ruling on whether two index funds or ETFs are substantially identical.
What our checker does with FXAIX and VFIAX
Our free checker treats FXAIX and VFIAX as two different securities. It matches a loss only against the same ticker and options on it, in every account you import, so a loss on FXAIX followed by a purchase of VFIAX, or the other way round, gets no flag at all. Its answers say so in its own words: “Matches the same ticker and options on it. It doesn't judge whether other securities are substantially identical.” The methodology lists cross-ticker pairs among its known limitations.
It does catch what is easy to miss by hand: the same ticker bought back in another account, an IRA or a spouse’s account whose files you import. Check your trades in the free checker; it runs in your browser and uploads nothing.
Ask a CPA or EA
This page sets out facts, not an answer for your return. Whether FXAIX and VFIAX are substantially identical for your sale is a question for a CPA or EA who can look at your trades, all your accounts and both funds’ current holdings. Bring the table above, the date of the loss sale and every purchase of either fund from 30 days before it to 30 days after. The wash sale calculator gives that window for any sale date.
Questions about FXAIX and VFIAX
Are FXAIX and VFIAX substantially identical?
We found no IRS ruling on FXAIX and VFIAX. They name the same index, are run by different companies and describe their strategies in different words. Ask a CPA or EA.
Does moving from FXAIX at Fidelity to VFIAX at Vanguard avoid a wash sale?
Not by itself. The rule looks at what you acquired, in any account at any broker. What matters is whether the two funds are “substantially identical”, which turns on all the facts and circumstances, not on which company holds the account.
More fund pairs
- Compare any two funds from the list, side by side.
- VOO and VFIAX
- VOO and FXAIX
- VTSAX and VFIAX
- All 18 fund pairs, by kind of pair.
- What counts as substantially identical: the clear cases and the gray zone.
- How to avoid a wash sale when you sell at a loss.