Wash sale fund comparison: two funds’ facts side by side
By Wash-Sale Guardian (who's behind it) · Published 2026-11-12 · Last updated 2026-11-12 · How the checker works
Pick two funds to see who issues each one, which index its issuer names and whether it is a share class of another fund, side by side, with what kind of pair the two make. Every fact is from the issuer’s own page, read on 2026-11-12. It shows facts, not a verdict: we found no IRS ruling on when two funds are “substantially identical”. Nothing you pick leaves this page.
What the comparison shows
- Each fund’s facts: its full name, its issuer, whether it is an ETF, a mutual fund or an exchange-traded product, the index its issuer names for it (or what it holds), with the issuer’s own words, and the fund it is a share class of, where the issuer says so.
- What kind of pair the two make: two share classes of one fund, two funds from different issuers on the same index, one issuer’s two funds on the same index, two funds on two versions of one index, two funds that hold the same asset (the two spot bitcoin funds), or funds on different indexes. That comes from the facts alone.
- What our checker does with the two tickers: it treats them as two different securities.
- A link to the pair’s own page, for the 18 pairs that have one, with the law in its own words and questions about that pair.
What it can’t tell you
- Whether a swap is a wash sale. IRS Publication 550 says “you must consider all the facts and circumstances in your particular case,” and we found no IRS ruling on any fund pair. Ask a CPA or EA.
- How much the holdings overlap. The comparison names the indexes; each issuer’s page lists its fund’s current holdings.
- Your dates and accounts. A loss is washed only by a purchase from 30 days before the sale to 30 days after, in any of your accounts. The wash sale calculator gives the window, and the free checker reads your broker files for the same ticker bought back anywhere.
- Funds that aren’t in the list. It includes only funds whose issuer’s page we could read; Schwab’s fund pages couldn’t be read on 2026-11-12.
Frequently asked questions
Does this comparison say whether two funds are substantially identical?
No. It shows what each fund is, from its issuer’s own page, and what kind of pair the two make. We found no IRS ruling on any fund pair, and IRC §1091, its regulation and Publication 550 name none. Ask a CPA or EA.
Why can’t I type in any ticker?
The comparison speaks only of funds whose issuer’s page we read and quoted, so every fact it shows has a source and a date. A fund that isn’t in the list hasn’t been checked that way yet.
Is what I pick sent anywhere?
No. The list and the facts are part of this page, and the comparison happens in your browser. Nothing you pick is stored or sent.
The rule itself, the clear cases and the gray zone are in what counts as substantially identical, and every pair with a page of its own is on the fund pairs page.